Carpeting Vs. Hardwood Flooring


When you enter the house or workplace, the first thing you see is flooring. The flooring may be the most important decoration part of your house. There are a lot of options available for flooring in terms of what kind of materials used as well as the style and appearance. 

More or less, people prefer hardwood or carpet to cover their concrete surfaces. They have different properties. They have different features. They meet your needs in different environments. In order to protect your surface, in order to achieve high efficiency, it would be good to know materials, fibers, and functioning. It allows you to make a proper choice and get to the best results.

There are many people who do not agree with other people about why we need to make a choice, why we need to decide which one, which feature makes another one more preferable, etc. They are absolutely two of the most popular flooring options, they go with any kind of home decor and any purpose. But how can we be sure which one is better for us?

You can see one of them more or less in every house but it doesn’t mean that they are similar. Actually, they don’t have a lot of similarities featurewise. Both have benefits as well as drawbacks. So, the right decision is a highly personal decision. It completely depends on your tastes, situation, and budget. You may consider outlining the differences between hardwood flooring and carpeting. It helps you to make a better decision about which is right for your places where you apply them.

Hardwood Flooring Virtues


Easy to Keep Clean


Cleanliness, cleaning, easy to clean, etc. are the most important factor when you decide on carpeting. In some cases, cleaning the carpet is not easy because of the fibers. Unwanted stand and odors easily can stay in the fibers and it won’t be easy to remove. 

So, if these properties are so important for you, or you are very lazy to clean frequently, hard flooring would be a good choice for you. They can be easily cleaned. You don’t even need a vacuum cleaner, you can clean it by wiping it. It doesn’t hide dust and dirt due to its solid surface. This feature especially important for health reasons. For example, respiration disorders and asthma. 

Long-lasting/ Durability 


If the installation is proper, hardwood is a better option for long-lasting flooring. It may even last generations. You can replace it according to your wish, or when you feel like you need to change it. On the other hand, carpeting needs to be replaced frequently due to its fibers even though it is easier to install. Hardwood flooring is a more economical option. It is budget-friendly. If you care about the money you spend, hardwood is a good investment. 



Scratches


Scratches happen unavoidably. By the time, because of walking, removing furniture, dropping something on it can cause scratches. But it doesn’t mean that they will stay forever. On the contrary, it is easy to cover these stretches with quick spot cleaning. If you think that you cannot fix it anymore because there are a lot, then you can replace it. On the other hand, for example, in order to prevent scratches, you can place soft pads under your furniture, use extra care, or leave your shoes at the door. With carpeting, scratches are not problems. They are already soft materials and they already protect your concrete flooring.

Low-allergy Surface


The fact that carpet can hold dust and microorganisms in fibers. It can affect anyone working or living in the same space as well. Especially if you suffer from allergies or any other respiratory health problem, it affects you more. Every time you walk across a carpet, millions of tiny particles that you cannot see with your eyes are cast into the air. However, life would be easier for you with hardwood flooring. Because all you have to do is wipe or sweep the hardwood in order to clean the surface.

Sound


By the time, you may hear the noise that you don’t understand where it is coming from. It can be a sound when you step on your flooring. Your flooring may be not good enough anymore and starts to loosen its features.  They are usually caused by flooring expanding or contracting. In terms of sound, instead of hardwood flooring, carpeting would be a better choice. If you had already had, for example, wall-to-wall carpet in your place, an area rug helps to reduce the noise. You can choose carpet over hardwood if you prefer peace and quiet environment.

Temperature


In terms of temperature, hardwood floors may not be the best option. If you prefer to go barefoot in your house, it is not a good idea to use hardwood. Also, since hardwood flooring cannot trap heat as well as carpeting, it could lead to increased heating bills in the winter because when you try to maintain a consistent temperature in your home it is a hard task to do it with hardwood flooring.



Can Be Refinished


With the hardwood flooring, it is easy to look new. When it is damaged, it can be renewed. The reason is not very important. This process involves sanding the surface after any defects, reapplying the stain, and using finishing products to ensure that the floor is completely rejuvenated. Depending on the thickness of the material used in hardwood flooring, you may able to repeat this process several times over the life of the floor.

Timeless Appeal


Hardwood flooring has timeless appeal because it has been used in places for more than hundreds of years. It has never stopped being popular and it has been chosen and preferred by people despite the constant shifts in style and trend by the time. You can always find a way to match your hardwood flooring with whatever colors and accessories you want and it can easily handle numerous different decorative choices.

Natural and Ecologically Friendly


If it is not made by plastic, hardwood flooring is made by wood material made from trees. Using trees is ecologically friendly because they can be replanted and renewed. On the other hand, carpeting is made largely from petroleum, which is a very limited resource. Most importantly, it is not natural in any way. However, if you want to purchase hardwood flooring, it is important to know its material whether it is real or plastic. You need to make sure that they are being harvested by an ecologically sound company in an environmentally friendly way.



Prestige/ Value


It is highly interesting that hardwood flooring is seen as a luxurious product. When you have hardwood carpeting in your place, people show more respect for your place and they think that you are a rich person. Depending on the type of wood you choose, hardwood flooring can create a sense of luxury and prestige when used in certain locations such as offices. For example, If you are preparing your home to sell, you don’t need to overlook the resale value of carpet vs. hardwood flooring. Hardwood flooring will be a perfect choice because it will increase the value of your home.

Hurst Hardwoods Acacia Hand Scraped Prefinished Engineered Wood Flooring 5″ x 1/2″


The quality of this hardwood flooring is fantastic. The machining of T&G is of great quality. Actual hardwood flooring comes in 12″ to 48″ random lengths. It has beautiful color variation looks highly natural in your place! https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01LW4BZ9E?tag=sates52carpet-20



Hurst Hardwoods Hickory Character (Jackson Hole) Prefinished Solid Wood Flooring 5″ x 3/4″


This 5″ Hickory Jackson Hole Character Hand Scraped Prefinished Solid hardwood flooring is perfect for those people wanting the natural characteristics of a real hardwood floor. This is a 3/4″ thick solid wood floor that can be nailed or stapled down. It is also highly recommended that using underlayment; a moisture barrier paper made from 100% recycled paper that contains zero VOCs. Each board is individually hand scraped by actual human hands and not by machine. These features give your flooring a worn and more rustic look and feel. Truly, it is a unique and one of a kind floor. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01LW7LRFV?tag=sates52carpet-20



VIF International Limited French Oak Cognac 5/8 in. Thick x 4-3/4 in. Wide x Varying Length Click Solid Hardwood Flooring


This product is very beautiful and looks great in your places! This refurbished product is tested and certified to look and work like new. The refurbishing process includes functionality testing, basic cleaning, inspection, and repackaging. The product ships with all relevant accessories, and may arrive in a generic box. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07CMB82PZ?tag=sates52carpet-20



Bruce Hardwood Floors Timberland Value Ground Oak Strip 3/4″ x 2 1/4″ – Cherry


. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07Y28LP54?tag=sates52carpet-20


Bare Decor EZ-Floor Interlocking Flooring Tiles in Solid Teak Wood Oiled Finish (Set of 10)


These hardwood tiles are awesome. These teak tiles are very high quality on the whole. The EZ-Floor interlocking flooring tiles come in an oiled finish in solid teak wood. No glue or tools are required in order to install. Just snap the interlocking tiles together is enough to install. It can be used for indoor or outdoor settings. It is perfect for an entryway, mudroom, deck, terrace, showers, bathrooms, pools or anywhere in between. Tiles can be removed and relocated if you need to do. Each tile is 9 solid pieces of solid teak wood on a plastic base. The teak is responsibly harvested in Indonesia. It is regularly inspected and every shipment receives Indonesian government clearance for compliance with responsible teak harvesting. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B014S7JPCO?tag=sates52carpet-20



Carpeting Virtues


Economical


Compared to hardwood materials, carpeting offers you more budget-friendly options. Even though it is considerably less expensive, there are plenty of options you can choose from. Depends on your need and home decor, you can find the most proper one fits your budget. Plus, carpeting is easy to install and you don’t need to spend extra money on installation, you can even save money. 

Longevity/ Lifespan/ Life Expectancy


Although carpeting is cheaper, it is needed to replaced earlier than it supposed to be. While the lifetime of your carpeting depends on its quality, life expectancy depends on how frequently you clean your carpet, the temperature of your place, the moisture level of your place, the traffic area on your carpeting, etc. Basic grade carpets typically need replacing in about five years. High-quality carpets can last 10 to 15 years.

Softness


The most important difference between them is the softness of carpeting. When you walk barefoot on carpeting, it feels very soft and great. This is particularly soothing in your living areas, where you want to promote an atmosphere of comfort, relaxation, and silence.

Warmth


As you can imagine, carpeting is much warmer than hardwood flooring. It doesnt matter what kind of carpeting but when you add some cloth on your concrete flooring, of course, it becomes warmer. Imagine you are living in very cold places, during winter it becomes like torture getting out of the bed. It is not only good for your feet, but it is also good for your room. It helps to insulate the room by ensuring that warmth remains indoors. It traps heat in your room on cold days and prevents cool air from escaping in the summer. It keeps energy and money costs down.



Physical Comfort


As a result of being soft and warm, carpeting becomes a comfortable flooring that you can stand on. Compared to hardwood flooring which causes pain in feet, ankles, and knees when you stand on for longer periods, flooring provides physical comfort. More than just having carpeting, as a plus if you have a dense foam underlayment, it becomes much more comfortable. We can count coziness as a physical comfort as well. It is one of the biggest benefits of carpeting over the hardwood flooring. 

Children Friendly


If you have kids, if they love playing, if instead of going out they spend more time at home, carpeting is a great option. It could be wall-to-wall or it could be an area rug that you put only in the children’s room or playroom. Because, as we mentioned before, the surface provides a comfortable and safe cushioned surface to play. Falls on carpeting is much less traumatic than falls on the hardwood flooring.

Allergens


It is a fact that carpet fibers easily traps allergens. That’s why vacuum cleaning is highly necessary. You have to vacuum frequently in order to get rid of those particles. Especially if you have a four-legged friend in your house, the vacuum cleaner should be a must in your house. Also, in rooms with high humidity and moisture levels, carpeting is prone to mold and mildew growth. So, if you are allergic, you need to be careful when you want to purchase a carpet.

Stains


Compared to hardwood flooring, of course, carpeting gets stain easily. If it is not treated quickly with a carpet cleaner, liquids, or whatever the stain is can soak into the padding or subfloor and leave an unwanted odor. If it is not cleaned immediately, that stain could be permanent. The smelling part is worse than the stain to deal with. Stains can cause discoloration as well. To resist discoloration, pre-treated synthetic fibers can be used. This may keep your carpeting looking like new. But you have to be aware that chemicals are often used in this process.

Maintenance


Maintenance is very important when you have carpets in your house. You need to do cleaning, vacuuming, and spot treating frequently, especially if you have children or four-legged friends in your house. 



Safety


Being soft makes carpeting a particularly safe flooring choice. Carpeting is a safer option than hardwood flooring for houses with pets, children, and the elderly. Because, if slips and falls happen, the carpet itself and the padding underneath can help prevent injury. With carpeting, you have a cushion across the entire room and it makes damage from an accident much less likely. On the other hand, can you imagine how it could be with hardwood flooring? A fall can result in injuries, broken bones, and broken objects. Safety could be a strong consideration in homes with small children or elderly, kindergarten, and elderly houses.

Sound-deadening/ Insulation


On the contrary to complaints about being loud of hardwood flooring, carpeting is the perfect choice for sound isolation. For example, if you live in a flat, your neighbors who live below can complain about hearing every footstep on the hardwood. With carpeting, though, the surface is covered with carpeting and padding, so now it is impossible for them to complain about any noise. Carpet acts as an insulator in this case and doesn’t let the noise pass easily. It provides peace and quiet that you are looking for. 

Versatility


The versatility of the carpet is an interesting and fun topic. Carpets can be bought in any size, shape, or color and it can still look fine. If you want to soften the look of your hardwood flooring and get some of the benefits of carpeting in a room, in order to increase the versatility of your flooring you can lay down an area rug to cover as much of the space of hardwood flooring as you wish. You can incorporate carpets in the decor of your home with many options. Hardwood flooring can be sanded and protected to match the style of your home decoration, but this can change over time. If this situation changes, you can change your carpet. They come in many different colors, sizes, and shapes.

Style


Carpeting has millions of options that fit your need, home decor, and budget. They are available in a variety of designs, shapes, styles, sizes, and colors in order to fit your design scheme. Depends on your home decor and style, you can make a bold and colorful statement or you can go basically neutral. And if you have uneven flooring, installing carpet can hide the imperfections and help level things out.

Trendiness


After all these advantages, even though it looks like people prefer carpets more often compared to hardwood flooring, hardwood is the most desirable option to cover the concrete floor. And not only for replacement, but also it is preferred in the new-built houses more. 

YJ.GWL Soft Indoor Large Modern Area Rugs


Fluffy area rugs are made of hypoallergenic material that ensures faux fur skin-friendly to family members, also there is no smell, no shed, and durable usage. Many kinds of beautiful colors to meet your style of the home. Opulent color makes a bold and dazzling fashion statement, the shaggy carpets are an easy way to decorate your places such as bedroom, kid’s room, and living room. Warm-up your floors with this attractive contemporary rug. The non-slip bottom design is ideal for wooden or other material floor surfaces and it doesn’t move at all. Embellish the floors and create a comfy landing spot with this shaggy rugs. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07X116D5S?tag=sates52carpet-20



Safavieh Madison Collection MAD611B Bohemian Chic Vintage Distressed Area Rug


They are beautiful high-quality area rugs. It has a Bohemian pattern with the right amount of color pop without being gaudy or overwhelming. It is not plush or super thick but it has just enough softness to provide comfort. It is a great quality, especially for the price. A stunning array of colors gives a designer look and feel to any room at a comfortable price point. Vintage effect is achieved from a power-loomed construction which ensures design consistency and durability. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01LXHXLML?tag=sates52carpet-20



Noahas Super Soft Modern Shag Gray Area Rugs


This is a good value of money. If you are looking for something temporary and awesome, then you can go for this one. Thickness is not too much but considering the money you are spending, that is the best value you can get. Don’t expect something extraordinary but the quality is pretty much reliable. It is really easy to clean. It is soft but not very thick. It is light to lift up and vacuum underneath yet it does not slip as it has small rubber patterns on the bottom. Dust and dirt on the surface can be removed easily. Please try to hand wash or wipe clean, that is the most convenient way with minimal efforts.

The fluffy area rug is made of faux velvet surface, sponge interlayer, and non-slip plastic spots bottom. Perfect for your bedroom/living room, this rug is the best option. There are different color options available which are gray, blue, creamy, black, gray-purple, green, hot pink, pink, purple, beige, white, indigo, and blush. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B06XR4YT58?tag=sates52carpet-20



nuLOOM Moroccan Blythe Runner Rug


It is a very cheap but fantastic value for money. It is soft, laid flat right away, looks great, and so far it is very easy to maintain! Power-loomed rug ensures long-lasting beauty and convenient upkeep, with virtually no shedding. It is a perfect fit for your living room, dining room, or hallway. It is designed with resiliency against everyday wear-and-tear. It is ideal for high traffic areas of the home. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01DW94RL8?tag=sates52carpet-20



Which Flooring Works for You?


Choosing proper flooring is one of the biggest decisions you have to make in terms of home renovation. And also it is one of the earliest decisions because carpeting is a big piece of decoration and you should make a decision it the beginning of the process. So, you should make a decision between hardwood flooring and carpeting. You may struggle with which flooring works best for your home and the unique needs of flooring.

You don’t need to choose only one type of flooring for the entire home. Each room can have a unique and different flooring type. As we mentioned above, each type of flooring has own pros and cons. The decisions you have made may come down who uses the room, where the room sits in the home, which characteristics you give importance more, how your room design is and whether health problems are a potential concern.

  • Carpeting: Basement, bedroom, den, family room, hallways, playroom, children’s room, offices
  • Hardwood flooring: Bedroom, entryway, dining room, hallway, kitchen, living room


Replacing Carpeting with Hardwood Floor


If you spend money on hardwood flooring for your floors, you need to evaluate your budget, preferences, traditions in your community, and your own taste. This is completely changing depends on the person. Each person has different tastes and each person’s expectation from the flooring is different.

People who have a very limited budget but in need of flooring, consider only laminate flooring. They don’t give even a change to hardwoods, as it is acceptable. Laminate flooring provides the same appearance as hardwood but a lower price. You should keep in mind that a flooring choice for people with allergies and asthma typically have a tendency to prefer a hard flooring surface. Because it will not hold dust. With flooring made from hardwood, there is often less dirt and fewer allergens than what is trapped in the fibers of the carpeting.

Once you make a decision, the care and maintenance of flooring are very important. As a conclusion, though, the decision you make about flooring in your living places should be based on your personal preference, your needs and your budget. It should be something affordable. At least if you intend to stay in the home or workplace for a few years, it should be something you like every time you see it.

Savaş Ateş

I'm a software engineer. I like history and reading about carpets. I like to play soccer too :)

Recent Posts